Details

King landowner and former Southlake Board member John Dunlap met King Mayor Steve Pellegrini to discuss the possible location of a new acute hospital in the municipality.  

I do not know when this meeting took place. Or if the land in question was still in the Greenbelt. (The Rice lands were removed from the Greenbelt by the Ford Government on 21 December 2022.)

I do not know if Dunlap sought the meeting as a private individual with substantial land holdings in King (adjacent to the Rice lands) or as a member of Southlake’s Board (until September 2022). Or, perhaps, he was wearing his hat as the land agent who sold the Schickedanz Greenbelt property to the developer, Michael Rice. 

If we are to disentangle all the strands, the date of the meeting is relevant. Perhaps Pellegrini made the first move. I don’t know. And I don’t know what else was on the agenda.

In May 2023 I filed a Freedom of Information request with King Township asking if Pellegrini had met John Dunlap at any point from 2019 to 2022 to discuss (a) the possible location of a new hospital in King and (b) the offer of land for such a purpose.

The Township now admits there was a meeting but I have to wait, perhaps, another month to get all the details as “third parties” have to be consulted. This is how the system works.

King Mayor Steve Pellegrini is on record saying he has been pressing for a new hospital in his municipality since 2019.

Moving the idea forward

Pellegrini told the King Sentinel:

“I have been moving this idea forward since 2019 – on different lands, with different landowners. At the time of our meeting, I brought the idea of a hospital forward to the Rice Group and they were open to discussion.”

In the light of that unequivocal statement, I filed an FOI with King Township asking for details of all meetings Pellegrini held with King landowners concerning the possibility of a site in King for a new hospital. That FOI is in the works.

Curiously, King tells me that over all those years from 2019 there was no formal mechanism in place for consulting landowners. It remains a mystery how Pellegrini “moved the idea forward”.

Truth

We know that Pellegrini doesn’t always tell the truth. And that complicates things.

The Globe and Mail editorial on Saturday nicely sums up the problem:

“The default belief in politics is that secrecy is less risky to the people in charge than transparency, and, in too many jurisdictions in Canada, that’s still true. Following access-to-information rules by the most parsimonious possible interpretation – or not at all – is the inevitable outcome.”

There are few, if any, consequences for politicians like Pellegrini who dissemble.

So. What do I want?

Pellegrini telling the truth would be a good place to start.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

See also: Timeline: Southlake and the sale of the Greenbelt lands in King

Details

Doug Ford has a long history of cronyism. 

So we shouldn’t be surprised to read in this morning’s Toronto Star that:

“More than a dozen of the recipients of a controversial new honour for Ontario lawyers donated to either Attorney General Doug Downey’s election campaign or his riding association.”

They will join Transportation Minister Caroline Mulroney KC who was called to the Ontario bar just a few days before the announcement.

But, for me, it is Ford’s brass neck that fascinates. 

He will always do what he thinks he can get away with. 

Gravy Train

Ten years ago Toronto City Councillor Doug Ford promised to end the gravy train at Queen’s Park. And now, as Premier, he regularly uses patronage to reward his friends and grease the wheels of government.

The man is totally shameless.

As it happens, twenty five years ago I argued in the UK Parliament for the abolition of Queen’s Counsel. The then Government reviewed the system and brought in some much needed reforms. The title QC (now KC) was retained. (Click read more below.)

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Update on 12 July 2023: From the Toronto Star: "I didn't see a list says Ford"

Update on 18 July 2023: From the Toronto Star: Advertising KC status may violate Law Society rules and We're gonna fix that process says Ford

Details

Arden Krystal is to retire in 2024.

Update from Newmarket Today

See also: Timeline: Southlake and the sale of the Greenbelt lands in King

Details

The Ford Government tells us the title “KC” is awarded to lawyers who have demonstrated a commitment to the pursuit of legal excellence in service to the Crown, the public and their communities. 

Breaking contracts

On 6 June 2019 at Queen’s Park Sandy Shaw MPP asked the then Attorney General, Caroline Mulroney, about the consequences of breaking contracts with the Beer Store. 

The rule of law means that governments… should follow the law… it is a principle that this Attorney General is sworn to uphold. That’s why it’s so concerning that this government is ripping up contracts and ignoring the rule of law—all for beer. In fact, the Canadian American Bar Association wrote the Attorney General an urgent letter and said that this government will “undermine the rule of law.” The Attorney General’s job is to uphold the rule of law. Has she spoken to the Premier about these serious concerns?

Refuses to answer

Mulroney refused to answer, passing the question to Vic Fedeli, then Minister of Finance, who accused the Liberals of giving the three global multinationals that own the Beer Store a sweetheart deal. 

“International companies understand our parliamentary system. They know that a new government isn’t bound by bad legislation.”

No compensation

Even if that means ripping up contracts without offering compensation.

We still don’t know if Caroline Mulroney KC believes this kind of behaviour undermines the rule of law.

She won’t tell us.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Update on 6 July 2023: From the Toronto Star: Doug Ford's Patronage Controversy builds on a Pattern of Poor Decision Making.

Update on 7 July 2023: From TVO: Thanks to Doug Ford we've got ourselves a good old fashioned patronage scandal

Details

This morning's Globe and Mail tells me Doug Ford has been quietly moving ahead with plans to sell beer in corner stores. 

It seems the great man has been mulling the pros and cons of pressing ahead with his unfulfilled promise from the 2018 election to allow convenience stores to sell beer.

I laughed out loud when I read about the closed door consultations, initiated by the Ministry of Finance, which:

"required all participants to sign non-disclosure agreements, keeping the talks secret."

When Ford vowed to break the Beer Store monopoly he overlooked the fact there would be huge costs in ripping up a watertight legal agreement with the big brewers. Ford then said legislation would protect the Province from the consequences of unilaterally breaking the contract. That ran into the sand.

Personally, I think it is totally weird that you can't buy beer at a corner store. When I first arrived in Canada from the UK it astonished me that beer and wine could only be purchased in Provincially regulated outlets. Now I'm used to it but, when I think about it, I still find it crazy. 

Christine and Dawn

I recall going to see my then MPP Christine Elliott in August 2019 to ask her when Andrew's Convenience store in Aurora would be allowed to sell beer and wines. Elliott was forever pointing to Andrew's Convenience store as the kind of local business that would benefit from the new, more liberal, policy. I remember her assistant, Dawn Gallagher Murphy, sitting in on the conversation, taking notes, saying nothing. Elliott assured me Andrew's would be selling beer in August 2020.

I couldn't see that happening when breaking the contract could cost $1 billion.

So this explains the secret consultation. Ford doesn't want anyone to remember his Buck-a-Beer fuelled promise to smash the Beer Store monopoly.

Making policy on the hoof

Ford makes policies on the hoof. They are not stress-tested before being announced to the public. This is a classic example.

In Ford's first term his media releases used to boast in a strapline at the bottom:

"Promise Made. Promise Kept."

But that kind of triumphalism was abandoned long ago.

Promises casually made are now casually broken.

I have a list.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Click Read More below for the G&M article

  • You are here:  
  • Home